
10 years ago I bought my first PDA. Since then my needs and technology used have changed a lot, but in essence it still is the same device, helping me to keep my life on track. I like to share this history, in the hope it will shed some light in what the trend of technology and my personal use is, but above all because I think it’s a good story to share.
My reason for buying my first PDA was simple: I hated the overhead, errors and omissions that came from copying appointments from our electronic system to my paper agenda. The company I worked had the policy that all appointments had to be registered in the central groupware system. My secretary also was able to make appointments in this system as well, so it was quite challenging to keep my paper copy of the calendar in sync with the electronic version. After several planning incidents with customers I concluded that my core competence was not copying appointments back and forth between two versions of my calendar: to me it was a huge waste of time and I wasn’t good at it either. Printing wasn’t an option either, since it only removed half of the duplication effort. So I decided to go the completely digital road.
It was august 1998 and Palm ruled with its Vx-line. Although it was a great looking device, I felt that it lacked the robustness I was looking for. It also demanded me to change my handwriting to something it would understand, instead of trying to understand mine. I hate it when technology requires me to change behaviour to use it. By accident I stumbled upon a newcomer in the market. I lived in Eindhoven, home town of Philips. They had just introduced the Philips Nino to the market, which in a small town like Eindhoven doesn’t go unnoticed. It was a first for them, but it looked great, so I decided to buy it, against market trend. I knew Philips would always deliver a high quality product that stood the test of time.
On hindsight that was a great decision. The Nino 300 is in fact a fantastic device. Although syncing my calendar to Novell Groupwise proved a little bit challenging at the time, the device was great in the field. It was a robust device with a strong touch-screen. It had room for 2 AA-batteries which kept it running for about two days. It also was ahead of its time by providing handwriting recognition which was about 85% accurate when it was decently trained. It was biggish but it was comfortable when you had it in your hands.
I quickly discovered that it wasn’t just a good tool for making appointments. I also learned that it could contain contacts, a to-do list and could take notes as well. That added functionality was actually a great boost for my personal effectiveness. You simply jotted down a task and it was recorded. I had to learn to execute the task, which still proves challenging, but that is another topic altogether. All my business cards went into the Nino as well, which allowed me to find them quickly when I needed them.
In mid-2000 I was assigned to run a project: the acceptance testing of the air traffic control center of EuroControl in Maastricht. Since I just moved to the other side of the country, I was looking at 5 to 6 hours of travel on a daily basis. Although that kind of long travel happened occasionally before, doing this on a daily basis really changed my needs. Since I had a Eurocontrol desktop, there wasn't much need to toss my laptop around. This made my Nino the only device for making notes during my trip. Although the occasional note would work fine, entering any long text quickly was painful; the recognition accuracy was too low and it was too slow when you are really in a flow: it basically broke the flow. I also got frustrated by the fact that I had to toss around my Nino and a MP3-player, which sounded a bit overdone to me.
Another new point was triggered by the level of isolation of an organization of EuroControl. It is a busy organization and it was disconnected to a fairly big degree: there literally was no outside news available there. That led to the situation where I started travelling at 6:00 and arrived home at about 20:00, without seeing any kind of news. Although my Nino had an internet browser, it could not deal with any kind of mobile phone acting like a modem. And I really wanted to stay in the loop.
So in December 2000 I bought the HP Jornada 548. Its clamshell-like design really felt great. It was a lot smaller than the Nino and had a colour screen. The screen was smaller, but it looked great. It could play MP3’s which I could store on the 32MB CF card I bought with it. Because it had a jog-wheel on the side, it could even be fitted inside my pocket and still change the song. Handwriting recognition was about 90% to 95%, which proved enough for the time, even when making longer texts. Energy wise it lasted about a day when used normally and about half a day when used as a MP3-player, but since I could charge it on both ends of the trip, that wasn’t much of a problem. I could also hook it up on my phone. By using my phone as a modem through infrared, dialing in to my own ISP, I could grab the news while travelling to and from work.
This was quite allright until in February 2002 I switched jobs and ended in a very small company of high-end IT specialists. My life became less predictable: I had customers at locations I had never been before, so I wanted to use maps to find my way around. TomTom Citymaps was the only maker of PDA-maps for the Netherlands, but they required more than the Jornada could give. Battery life became another major issue: I could not charge at both ends of the trip anymore. I also got fed up with InfraRed for grabbing e-mail and browsing: it wasn’t robust enough and when you are on a platform of a train station it becomes a bit of a juggle to set it up while boarding a train and still grab that big attachment. There had to be a better way. So I started looking for something new.
In that time, there were 2 big competitors in the Bluetooth space: the HP Ipaq 3970 and the Fujitsu Siemens Loox. The Loox was a better looking device, better styled for my job. The Ipaq was bulky and far less appealing with its shiny surfaces and buttons. The Loox had an innovative ergonomic design with far less toy-like appearance. So after a wait of a couple of months I could finally buy one: I was the first in the Netherlands with that device. It gave me my maps. The Loox gave me bluetooth, which worked great with my phone and horrible with anything else. In combination with my phone it was great: my phone could stay in my bag while I grabbed my e-mail. However, it took me weeks to get any kind of bluetooth sync working with my laptop. It has some funny hardware bugs, like the backlight of the screen not turning on when it was too dark, but it was a great device. It was robust, light and quite reliable.
A couple of months later, we were taken over by a bigger company: CIBIT. Initially that didn’t mean much for my work, but later on in the process, I got more internationally oriented work. International work isn’t much different than national work, apart from the fact that many things embedded in your daily routine are ridiculously expensive. One of these things was GPRS. Although it was not cheap to use it in the Netherlands either, it reached absurd prices when used abroad: $50 per megabyte was not an exception. So I had to find another way of grabbing my e-mail and read the news. In mid 2004 I discovered that many places started to offer WiFi, some of them even for free as long as you were willing to pose as a paying customer. If I could grab the e-mail through WiFi it would be a huge improvement because I could still be as responsive as usual even while I was abroad.
There was a small wave of mobile devices with WiFi and I quickly discovered the HP Hx4700. Apart from its cryptic number it did provide a superbly engineered device. It looked great in its dark metal finish, not shiny at all. It also had a huge 4" screen, the thing I longed for since I left the Nino. It was great for note taking. It was a brilliant VGA screen which meant that everything was a bit sharper, which is easier on the eyes.
Near the end of 2004 my personal phone (an Ericsson T39m) was end-of-life: I had it for about 3 years and it was beaten up. I decided to change my simple personal phone for the more sophisticated i-Mate Jam. It was the first Windows Mobile power phone with a decent formfactor, which was important to me. It provided some more comfort when browsing the web, as well as a decent sync of my contacts to my phone, which comes in handy when you have a lot of people to keep track of. I really liked its candy-bar formfactor and its modest size. It would allow me to leave my Hx4700 home when away for pleasure. It worked quite well, although the smaller screen proved challenging for quick note-taking and inputting parts of names with handwriting recognition.
This was resolved a year later by the i-Mate K-Jam that had a keyboard. This was the Jam, but then with a keyboard. The frustration with the limited screen when taking notes was so big, that I was really happy to pay for another device. I loved the Jam, but the keyboard on the K-Jam simply completed too many important scenarios for me to let it slip by.
Also at the same time, i-Mate introduced the JasJar. A VGA device that also made calls (yes, it was that bad). First of all, it merged my busisness phone and PDA, making the number of devices to be managed one less. To me, it improved my effectiveness when travelling for business a lot. Until then I used my Hx4700 while travelling. Which was great, but writing e-mail is a lot easier if you do have a larger keyboard and can press send and forget about it. Actually the later spooked my mind a lot: I did not want to become too dependent on a shaky bluetooth connection to send critical e-mail: it was a huge stress factor for me to constantly check if the mail wasn't stuck due to some connection error. I just wanted to press send and get on with my life. Although it certainly had its limitations, it was a huge improvement with respect to the stand alone Hx4700.
So I replaced my PDA and two phones by two smartphones at the end of 2005, which was quite a nice and efficient setup. However, in the beginning of 2007 I discovered a new kid on the block: the HTC P4350, which fixed major frustrations with the JasJar: its collosal size. I kept the K-Jam as business device, but I soon replaced it. The K-Jam had a smallish keyboard. The P4350 had a much better keyboard, and that was actually all I needed to resolve all my frustrations.
Looking back at this effectiveness experience, what you see is that many changes have been driven by optimizing technology to become more comfortable. The core functionality has never actually changed, it was just the connectivity and integration that changed, as well as the size.
Posted on Sunday 17 of August, 2008 [22:32:10 UTC]